Showing posts with label Benzodiazepines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Benzodiazepines. Show all posts

How to help seniors eliminate benzodiazepines, opioids and other medications

I read the “American Geriatrics Society 2019 Updated AGS Beers Criteria® for Potentially Inappropriate Medication Use in Older Adults” and thought it might be useful to share some perspectives that were helpful to my senior patients.

Gladys was referred to me by one of my other senior patient.  She had moved to Ajax and placed herself on another family doc’s waitlist.  She finally got a call to meet the new physician; and was told after their first meeting that she can’t be accepted due to her need for sleeping pills.
I remember in our first meeting, Gladys was wearing makeup, thin, slightly tremulous, anxious and earnest.
I think after I finally assured her that I will do my best to look after her; her attention switched from the fear of rejection to the fear of running out of her sleeping pills.
She explained to me that she has been on her sleeping pills for well over 20 years and can sleep only a little even with the meds; and that she must have them or she can’t sleep at all.  I explained to her the nature of addiction; that there is a real need, a substitute solution and a real solution.
I explained to her the real need is an increased ability to pay attention.  An increased ability to pay attention will allow her to redirect her attention from her incessant thoughts to other aspect of her moment by moment experience, such as tactile sensation. I explained that such increased ability will not only help her quiet her thoughts but also help her with day time anxiety.
I then explained to her that benzodiazepines, like all “depressive” substances (alcohol, cannabinoids, opioids, OTC sleep aids) are all substitutes.  I then explained to her the problems with substitutes are three fold; real needs unmet, mental suffering associated with the 4c’s of addiction, the host of side effects (relevant examples useful for illustration are plentiful) of the substitutes.
Finally I explained to her that I can show her mental exercises that will improve her attention.  She repeatedly expressed her doubts but when I pointed out to her that things weren’t really satisfactory even with the pills; she hesitantly agreed to listen and to give it a try.  I showed her how to BAM (Breath Awareness meditation).
Within 2 weeks, she was sleeping without benzodiazepines or any seditions.  I also encouraged her to increase non-starchy vegetable intake towards 400 grams per day.  In a short time, she quit her antidepressants and began volunteering at a nursing home. I should also mention that Gladys was 76 years old.
This strategy has worked in my practice over and over again. No patient leaves with a script for any habit forming substance without a “heart to heart” conversation on diet and addiction.  I have not had to start anyone on benzodiazepine for a long time.

One of my patient brought her elderly mom, Edith, to see me for the first time.  Edith was a 87 year old lady sitting in a wheelchair. Edith used to live in the city independently but had to move in with her daughter recently due to the loss of power in her left leg and intractable sciatica.  She had already seen the neurosurgeon and was told that there was no surgical solution. She had been to ER on several occasions. At her last ER visit, her hydromorphone dose was tittered up. She can no longer walk, lost her appetite, became constipated, continue to suffer intolerable pain, felt generally weaker and a sense of hopelessness.  She was placed on waitlist for bed in a chronic care facility.
I explained to her the importance of getting off the opioids; and for her to discover core muscle actions that restores sensations to her left leg.  I explained to her ways to use increased intra-abdominal pressures to stretch para-lumbar muscles and decompress the lumbar spine. I asked her to begin these exercises while laying in bed.  She was fortunate to have her dedicated daughter’s support. (Her daughter learnt to manage her own fibromyalgia using mindfulness-based practices and uses no analgesics.)
Within a month, by following those instructions, she stopped using her wheelchair, hydromorphone and laxatives.  Her appetite was restored and her pain managed with mindful posture core muscle engagements.

Then there is Anna, a friend’s elderly mother, who began living in a retirement home following her coronary bypass surgery.  I was asked to help. Post-op, she was unable to eat, losing weight, weak, unable to get out of bed, diapered and depressed and wanting to die.  Her sulphonyluria, DDP4 and metformin were eliminated and replaced with basal insulin and a diet containing 5 oz of non-starchy vegetables three times a day.  Now her am glucose is 7.2-8.4 based on glucose logs faxed weekly to my office. I can always tell when she is off her diet. Even though the nutritional order is in her chart, implementation by her retirement home is inconsistent.  I think I will give her director of home a call and share the “Effect of eating vegetables before carbohydrates on glucose excursions in patients with type 2 diabetes” - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3882489/

Anna is now waking with a walker.  She know to keep her back nice and straight, chest out and cores engaged.  She only uses the walker for balance.

She had some transient SVT post-CABG.  She is now off amiodarone, NOAC, furosemide, potassium and magnesium.

She is also off her quetiapine, mirtazapine and pantoprazole.  

She now no longer asking Jesus to take her;  instead she loves life, lives one moment at a time, says her rosaries every night and asks God to send an angel to sleep with her.  She now sleeps soundly every night till the morning. She tells me how much she enjoys her family and last night’s Valentine’s dinner at the retirement home.

Disclaimer:

To respect patient privacy, all names are changed.
These are specific examples which may or may not apply to you.  Please only change or discontinue medication under guidance of your own physician.





Nature of addiction

I read this morning that The Saskatchewan College of Pharmacy Professionals (SCPP) has approved in principle a ban on exempted codeine products (ECPs).

Narcotics (including ECP) are addicting substitute solutions to real unmet needs.  I believe policies, regardless of intention, that bans “substitutes” such as ECP or legalizes cannabis are in themselves “substitute” solutions for the growing issue of addiction in society.  Individuals or governance that are unaware of the nature of addiction will simply switch from one substitute to the next easiest accessible substitute.

My perspective on Cycle of Addiction ( reminiscent of some computer programming language)
Sample program 1: Diabetes type 2 (sugar addiction)

1. Real need: Whole Foods & appropriate physical activity
2. Craving from needs unmet: hunger
3. Easy substitute: simple carbohydrates
4. Brief relieve from hunger
5. Craving recurs from needs unmet: hunger
6. Go to 3.

Sample program 2: Opioid crisis (opioid addiction)

1. Real need: wholefood, appropriate physical activity, ability to pay attention to what is important & self-compassion
2. Craving from needs unmet: pain & suffering
3. Easy substitute: opioids
4. Brief relieve from pain & suffering
5. Craving recurs from needs unmet: pain & suffering
6. Go to 3.

Sample program 3: Workaholism (intentionally left blank. It may be familiar to some readers)

Three challenges of addictions are: 1. Suffering caused by a real need unmet. 2. Side effects of the substitutes.  3. Vulnerability to other harmful substitutes.
I believe much more conversations at an individual and system level about the true nature of addiction are needed.

My conversation with patients about addiction.

I am sometimes asked by patient to prescribe benzodiazepines, cannabis or opioids.

My approach is similar for all medications and substances with potential addiction properties.
1. I explain to them that no one (for emphasis of course, I point out the obvious) including myself is “immune” to addiction; that given the situation, anyone can become addicted. (They usually don’t believe me at this point)
2. I then explain to them the mechanism or cycle of addiction (fear of some suffering/ craving for end of it; seeking a quick relieve / a substitute solution; relieve from suffering; effect of quick solution begin to wear out; triggers the fear of suffer... then the cycle’s intensity compounds); I talk about some real life examples; and there is no lack of stories.  By now, they begin to see how addiction applies to them personally.
3. I then help them understand the lengthy list of other unintended and serious side effects of the substitute solution ( Eg.  Increased risk of falls in seniors; respiratory arrest, quality of life, etc.; I try to use examples most relevant to the individual.
4. I ask them and help them identify what it is their suffering the are hoping to alleviate.
5. I then offer them a real solution to their sufferings.  (Eg. my Basic Wellness Messages)
https://www.whatisharewithpatients.com/2019/02/a-family-physicians-basic-wellness.html?m=1
6. In my experience, above approach has resulted in various satisfactory outcomes; many embrace the knowledge and come to attend my wellness groups and learn more about the Basic Wellness Messages;

some are disappointed but still respect the time spent and reasoning; none leaves with a quick fix or substitute solution without a clear understanding and an agreement on a solid plan to eliminate the substitute with the real solution.

In my opinion, the key ingredient of addiction management are:
1. That I take the time.
2. That I understand addiction is a common humanity. ( remove stigma and judgement of which self-judgement or shame is most intense)
3. That I explain the mechanism of addiction in a way that can be understood by the individual
4. That I help find a real solution to replace a substitute.
5. That a reasonable plan is agreed upon to safely wean off the substitutes and apply the real solution.
6. That I use “physician-led self-management education and support groups” to help patients begin personal transformations.
https://www.whatisharewithpatients.com/2018/12/why-stethescope-and-spinach.html?m=1

I believe we need a system solution that supports more conversations at an individual level.

I see each patient encounter as a valuable opportunity to engage patient in a conversation on the nature of addiction; whether it is to sugar or opioids or anything else for that matter.

I then enrol them in our weekly “physician-led self-management education groups” to continue our journey of awareness and wellness.

I have ran this group for over a year now.  It has proven to be an effective way to help my patients.  

There has been many stories.  John’s story stands out (fiction name).  He has eliminated the substitutes in his life (street drugs, alcohol, cannabis and tobacco) and replaced it with what he truly need (wholefood, appropriate physical activity, improve ability to pay attention to what is important & self-compassion through practice of BAM)

For type 2 diabetes, John’s HbA1C was 11.5 on SGLT, DDP4 and metformin. His last HbA1C was 5.6.  This type results is not uncommon in my patient population. According to a study published in Lancet, “at 12 months, almost half of participants achieved remission to a non-diabetic state and off antidiabetic drugs. Remission of type 2 diabetes is a practical target for primary care”

John meditates daily with his wife and eats 400 grams of non-starchy vegetables per day.  
He enjoys great relationships with his wife, daughter and his grandchildren.  We hope to collaborate and share our perspectives on the importance of vegetables in our diet.

The case of Type 2 diabetes.

According to Shaun Loney, author of “The beautiful bailout - how a social innovations scale-up will solve government’s priciest problems”:

Annual health care cost per Canadian = $6604
Annual health care cost per Canadian with diabetes = $26416
Difference per year = $19812
Even though I don’t have the numbers for opioid crisis, I believe they are also staggering.

It appears to me there is plenty of money to do wonder if we can simply target the real needs rather than direct most of our attention to the substitutes or substitute it with a yet more costly substitute without a clear vision.
https://www.whatisharewithpatients.com/2019/01/a-solution-at-addiction.html?m=1

Disclaimer:
Above are my personal opinions based on my clinical experience.

My conversation with patients about addiction

I am sometimes asked by patient to prescribe benzodiazepines, cannabis or opioids.

My approach is similar for all medications and substances with potential addiction properties.
1. I explain to them that no one (for emphasis of course, I point out the obvious) including myself is immune to addiction; that given the situation, anyone can become addicted. (They usually don’t believe me at this point)
2. I then explain to them the mechanism or cycle of addiction (fear of some suffering/ craving for end of it; seeking a quick relieve / a substitute solution; relieve from suffering; effect of quick solution begin to wear out; triggers the fear of suffer... then the cycle’s intensity compounds); I talk about some real life examples; and there is no lack of stories.  By now, they begin to see how addiction applies to them personally.
3. I then help them understand the lengthy list of other unintended and serious side effects of the substitute solution ( Eg.  Increased risk of falls in seniors; respiratory arrest, quality of life, etc.;  I try to use examples most relevant to the individual.
4. I ask them and help them identify what it is their suffering the are hoping to alleviate.
5. I then offer them a real solution to their sufferings.  (Eg. my Basic Wellness Messages)
6. In my experience, above approach has resulted in various satisfactory outcomes; many embrace the knowledge and come to attend my wellness groups and learn more about the Basic Wellness Messages;

some are disappointed but still respect the time spent and reasoning; none leaves with a quick fix or substitute solution without a clear understanding and an agreement on a solid plan to eliminate the substitute with the real solution.

In my opinion, the key ingredient of addiction management are:
1. That I take the time.
2. That I understand addiction is a common humanity. ( remove stigma and judgement of which self-judgement or shame is most intense)
3. That I explain the mechanism of addiction in a way that can be understood by the individual
4. That I help find a real solution to replace a substitute.
5. That a reasonable plan is agreed upon to safely wean off the substitutes and apply the real solution.
6. That I use “physician-led self-management education and support groups” to help patients begin personal transformations. Disclaimer: 
Above are my personal opinions based on my clinical experience.

Chapter 2: The Involuntary Thought

  ... Thoughts arise like mist... Exploring the gentle emergence of thoughts and the sovereignty of sensation in our shared field of presenc...